5. “Rowdy” Roddy Piper
Roddy Piper defeated The Undertaker in a ‘Body Bag Match’ on September 12, 1991 during the Main Event of an untelevised House Show in Bangor, Maine. Whether Piper wrestled as a Replacement for someone else (Sid?) that night isn’t known, but that’s most likely the case. He would beat The Undertaker yet again the next month on October 07, 1991 in Sheffield, England, this time via DQ.
6. Tito Santana
Allthough not beating him clean, even Tito Santana (shortly before being repackaged as “El Matador”) holds a win over the Deadman.
In a match airing on spanish Television as part of a WWF World Tour 1991 Special, the likeable Mexican used Paul Bearer’s Urn to get the pinfall victory.
